Option 1: A regular TV
A consumer TV on the wall showing cable, a streaming channel or a USB slideshow. It's the cheapest way to start.
- Good: low upfront cost, simple to set up.
- Not so good: cable news and other people's ads don't promote your business. USB slideshows need someone to update them by hand, so they rarely change. Home TVs aren't designed to run all day, every day.
Option 2: Do-it-yourself signage software
A signage app or player that lets you build and schedule content yourself.
- Good: flexible, remotely updatable, templates to start from.
- Not so good: someone on your team has to learn it, design the content and keep it current. In busy practices that job usually slips, and the screen goes stale.
Option 3: Fully managed digital signage
A provider supplies the screen, installs it, creates the content and keeps it updated for you.
- Good: professional, branded content; nothing for your team to run; updates happen without you thinking about it; hardware problems are the provider's job.
- Not so good: a monthly cost, and usually a contract.
Side by side
| Regular TV | DIY software | Fully managed | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who makes the content? | Someone else (cable) or you | You | The provider, approved by you |
| Branded to your business? | No | If you design it | Yes |
| Staff time each month | Low, but nothing changes | Ongoing | Approvals only |
| Live info (weather, transit) | No | Sometimes, with setup | Included |
| Built for all-day use | Usually not | Depends on your hardware | Commercial display |
| If it breaks | Your problem | Your problem | The provider fixes it |
Which is right for you?
If you just want something on the wall and don't mind what it shows, a TV is fine. If you have someone on the team who enjoys design and has time every week, DIY software can work well.
If you want the screen to look professional, promote your own services and stay current without adding work for your team, managed signage is usually the better fit.
Questions to ask any managed signage provider
- Who creates the content, and do I approve it before it goes live?
- How many updates are included each month?
- Who owns the hardware, and what happens if it fails?
- Does the screen connect to my network, and how is it kept separate?
- What happens if the internet goes down?
- How long is the contract, and how do I cancel?
Phosphor Pixel's answers to all of these are on our FAQ page. We provide fully managed screens in Brooklyn and across New York City, from $350 a month.